Question 1

What is the "fiduciary duty" that Virginia HOA board members owe to homeowners?

Accepted Answer

In Virginia, board members have a legal responsibility known as fiduciary duty, which requires them to act with care, loyalty, and within their authority. This means they must act as diligent officers of a corporation, prioritizing the association's needs over personal interests. For example, a board cannot ignore documented erosion on common property just to keep dues low for themselves, as they are legally obligated to maintain the community's assets and follow the governing documents.

Question 2

What steps should a homeowner take if the board ignores a maintenance issue like erosion?

Accepted Answer

The process typically begins with gathering thorough documentation, including photos and a history of correspondence. In Virginia, homeowners should first follow their association’s formal internal dispute resolution procedure to seek a "final adverse decision." If the issue remains unresolved, the homeowner can then file a complaint with the Common Interest Community Ombudsman within the Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation (DPOR), usually within thirty days of the board's final decision.

Question 3

Do homeowners have a right to see the association's financial and maintenance records?

Accepted Answer

Yes, under the Virginia Property Owners’ Association Act, members in good standing have the right to access most records, including financial books, meeting minutes, and contracts. A homeowner must provide written notice—typically five business days in advance—and state a "proper purpose" for the request. Investigating how maintenance funds are allocated or checking if the board is following its "Reserve Study" for major repairs are considered valid reasons for requesting these documents.

Question 4

What legal options are available if internal disputes and the Ombudsman process fail?

Accepted Answer

Homeowners can escalate the matter to the General District Court if the damages or repair costs are under fifty thousand dollars, which is often faster and less expensive than Circuit Court. Alternatively, many Virginia associations allow for Alternative Dispute Resolution, such as mediation, where a neutral third party helps reach a compromise. It is important to note that if a homeowner wins a court case, Virginia law often requires the association to pay the homeowner’s attorney fees.

Question 5

How does Virginia law protect homeowners from selective enforcement or harassment?

Accepted Answer

Boards are required to treat all residents equally and follow "due process," which includes providing written notice and a hearing before levying fines. If a board ignores a rule for most residents but strictly enforces it against one person—known as selective enforcement—they are likely to lose in court. Additionally, if the board's actions create a hostile environment or target someone based on age or disability, it may violate the federal Fair Housing Act.

Virginia HOA disputes and holding your board accountable

How This Personalized Podcast Was Made